| | |
Careers

5096 Island 865
Baxter Muskoka L0K 1S0

$575,000
Residential Freehold beds: 2 baths: 1.0

Main Photo: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 1: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 2: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 3: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 4: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 5: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 6: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 7: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 8: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 9: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 10: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 11: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 12: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 13: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 14: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 15: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 16: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 17: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 18: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 19: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 20: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 21: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 22: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 23: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 24: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 25: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 26: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 27: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 28: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 29: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 30: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 31: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 32: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 33: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 34: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Photo 35: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
X12201351
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
1
Welcome to your dream escape just 1 hour and 40 minutes from the GTA and a quick 2-minute boat ride from the marina. This well-maintained, boat-access cottage is set on a private and picturesque 0.674-acre lot with 138 feet of pristine waterfront on a quiet bay, offering the perfect blend of tranquility, comfort, and adventure. The charming 2-bedroom cottage features a bright and airy open-concept layout, enhanced by vaulted ceilings and tasteful décor throughout. The living room is warmed by a fireplace with airtight insert, and the kitchen with dining area is ideal for gathering with family and friends. Laminate flooring in the kitchen and living room adds to the cottages clean, updated feel, while a 3-piece bathroom ensures all the essentials are covered. Step outside to a spacious deck that overlooks the sparkling water, ideal for morning coffee, afternoon lounging, or evening cocktails with a sunset view. A large dock with deep water offers excellent swimming and boating access, while a sandy beach area along the shore is perfect for children and pets to play. As the sun sets, gather around the fire pit overlooking the bay and soak in the serene views and golden light dancing on the water. An 8' x 12' Bunkie adds extra accommodation space for guests, making this property a wonderful option for hosting weekend getaways or summer holidays. Whether you're looking for a peaceful place to recharge or a lakeside hub for fun-filled days on the water, this turnkey property delivers an unforgettable cottage experience. Accessible, inviting, and fully ready for the season, this is your opportunity to own a slice of waterfront paradise.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
Bungalow
Approx. Age:
51-99
Total Approx Floor Area:
< 700
Lot Size:
.50-1.99
Depth:
193'1"
Frontage:
138'
Topography:
Rocky, Rolling, Wooded/Treed, Partially Cleared, Sloping
Direction Faces:
North
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
1.0
Water supply:
Other
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
2
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
5
Fractional Ownership:
No
Heating type:
Other
Heating Fuel:
Wood
Fireplaces:
1
Foundation:
Block, Piers
Roof:
Metal
Basement:
None
Fireplace Features:
Fireplace Insert, Wood
Fireplace/Stove:
Yes
Alternative Power:
None
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Other Structures:
Aux Residences, Shed
Parking Features:
None
Parking Spaces:
0
Total Parking Spaces:
0.0
Rural services:
Electricity Connected
Family Room:
No
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Not Subject to HST
Assessment:
$237,000
Assessment Year:
2025
Taxes:
$1,956 / 2024
Assessment:
$237,000.00 / 2025
Georgian Bay
Baxter
Muskoka
Lake/Pond, Wooded/Treed, Sloping, Marina
Water Heater Owned
Deck
None
Unknown
None
Inside Furniture, Outside Furniture
Personal Possessions, Power Tools, Kase sign by inside front door, Spoons on wall between mounted water skis, Oil lamp on mantle, Kraft box on mantle, Lantern on mantle, Tea tray on wall by dining table, Antique iron on fireplace, Paddle Board and Paddle.
None
Wood
138'
Dock, Marine Rail, Stairs to Waterfront, Beach Front
Direct
Clean, Rocky, Deep
Owned
North East
Bay, Lake, Trees/Woods, Water
Direct
By Water, Water Only
South Bay
Georgian Bay
Bay
Bunkie
Private
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Living Room
17'7" × 11'6"
Fireplace Insert, Laminate, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Main
Kitchen
17'7" × 7'7"
Laminate, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Main
Bedroom
9'4" × 8'5"
Vaulted Ceiling(s), Laminate
Main
Bedroom 2
9'4" × 8'11"
Vaulted Ceiling(s), Laminate
Main
Foyer
6'5" × 2'7"
Laminate, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Floor
Ensuite
Pieces
Other
Main
No
3
6'5" x 6'4" 3 Pc Bath, Ceramic Floor
Utilities Cable:
No
Utilities Telephone:
Available
Utilities Gas:
No
Utilities Hydro:
Yes
Utilities Water:
No
Water Supply Types:
Lake/River
Sewers:
No
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Holding Tank
Air Conditioning:
None
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Date Listed:
Jun 06, 2025
  • Photo 1: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 1 of 35
  • Photo 2: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 2 of 35
  • Photo 3: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 3 of 35
  • Photo 4: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 4 of 35
  • Photo 5: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 5 of 35
  • Photo 6: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 6 of 35
  • Photo 7: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 7 of 35
  • Photo 8: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 8 of 35
  • Photo 9: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 9 of 35
  • Photo 10: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 10 of 35
  • Photo 11: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 11 of 35
  • Photo 12: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 12 of 35
  • Photo 13: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 13 of 35
  • Photo 14: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 14 of 35
  • Photo 15: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 15 of 35
  • Photo 16: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 16 of 35
  • Photo 17: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 17 of 35
  • Photo 18: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 18 of 35
  • Photo 19: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 19 of 35
  • Photo 20: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 20 of 35
  • Photo 21: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 21 of 35
  • Photo 22: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 22 of 35
  • Photo 23: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 23 of 35
  • Photo 24: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 24 of 35
  • Photo 25: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 25 of 35
  • Photo 26: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 26 of 35
  • Photo 27: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 27 of 35
  • Photo 28: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 28 of 35
  • Photo 29: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 29 of 35
  • Photo 30: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 30 of 35
  • Photo 31: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 31 of 35
  • Photo 32: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 32 of 35
  • Photo 33: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 33 of 35
  • Photo 34: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 34 of 35
  • Photo 35: 5096 Island 865 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12201351
    Photo 35 of 35

Virtual Tour

Listed by Sotheby's International Realty Canada
Data was last updated August 4, 2025 at 04:15 AM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
87
Avg list price:
$899,000
Min list price:
$475,000
Max list price:
$4,895,000
Avg days on market:
67
Min days on market:
2
Max days on market:
527
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Baxter. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
powered by myRealPage.com